Looking for the best payroll outsourcing companies for your U.S. business?
Managing payroll in-house can be time-consuming, complex, and costly—especially with ever-changing tax regulations and compliance requirements. In fact, a study by Deloitte found that 73% of businesses outsource payroll to improve compliance and reduce operational costs.
Outsourcing payroll services can streamline your payroll process, minimize errors, and free up valuable time to focus on growing your business. But with so many options available, how do you determine which provider best fits your needs?
In this article, we’ll explore the top 10 payroll outsourcing companies for U.S. businesses, highlighting their key features, pricing, and what sets them apart.
NEED PAYROLL SUPPORT?
Hire a Payroll specialist with 1840 & Company to streamline your payroll processes and ensure compliance.
What Is Payroll Outsourcing?
Payroll outsourcing is the process of hiring a third-party provider to manage payroll-related tasks such as wage calculations, tax withholdings, direct deposits, and compliance with federal and state labor laws. A key feature of payroll outsourcing services is the use of direct deposit, which allows employees to receive their funds quickly and efficiently. Instead of handling these complex and time-consuming processes in-house, businesses delegate them to specialized payroll service providers who ensure accuracy, efficiency, and legal compliance.
For U.S. businesses, payroll outsourcing is more than just processing employee paychecks—it’s about reducing compliance risks, minimizing administrative burden, and ensuring seamless payroll operations. With constantly changing tax regulations and the potential for costly payroll errors, outsourcing to a trusted provider can help companies avoid penalties, save time, and focus on strategic business growth. Whether a business has 10 employees or 10,000, outsourcing payroll ensures smooth, hassle-free operations while improving overall efficiency.
QUICK TIP: 27% of small businesses report spending over 6 hours per month on payroll—time that could be better spent on strategic growth.
When Should a Business Outsource Payroll?
Deciding when to outsource payroll depends on several factors, but the key indicator is when managing payroll in-house becomes too time-consuming, error-prone, or costly. For many businesses, this happens as they scale, hire employees in multiple states, or struggle to keep up with evolving tax regulations.
Outsourcing can help manage payroll responsibilities, which include calculating amounts, preparing taxes, and handling reports, thereby reducing the complexity and time commitment involved.
According to IRS data, One-third of small businesses are penalized for payroll errors due to tax mistakes, costing an average of $845 per year in fines.
Here are some clear signs that it’s time to consider payroll outsourcing:
- Payroll processing is taking too much time – If payroll is consuming more than 5-10 hours per month for small businesses (under 50 employees) or 20+ hours for mid-sized businesses (50-500 employees), it’s a sign that inefficiencies are slowing down operations. For larger businesses, payroll can take several days per pay cycle, making automation and outsourcing a necessity. If payroll is pulling key executives or HR teams away from strategic priorities, outsourcing can free up valuable time.
- Increased risk of tax compliance errors – With complex IRS regulations, payroll tax errors can lead to costly penalties. A professional payroll provider ensures compliance with federal, state, and local tax laws.
- Frequent employee turnover – Industries with high turnover, like retail or hospitality, require constant payroll updates, making outsourcing a smart way to manage changes efficiently.
- Multi-state or global expansion – Payroll laws vary by state and country. If your company is expanding, outsourcing ensures compliance with regional payroll requirements.
- Need for cost-effective payroll solutions – Hiring and training an internal payroll team can be expensive. Outsourcing provides access to payroll experts at a fraction of the cost.
By outsourcing payroll at the right time, businesses can minimize risks, streamline operations, and focus on what matters most—growth and profitability.
What to Look for in an Outsourced Payroll Service Provider
Choosing the right payroll outsourcing provider is a strategic decision that goes beyond just processing paychecks. A professional provider can handle various payroll functions, such as payroll taxes and direct deposits, allowing businesses to outsource all or specific tasks based on their needs. The ideal provider should not only ensure accuracy and compliance but also integrate seamlessly with your business operations, scale as you grow, and provide the right level of support. Here are the key factors to consider when selecting a payroll outsourcing partner:
1. Compliance & Security: Avoid Costly Mistakes
Payroll providers must stay updated with federal, state, and local tax regulations to prevent compliance errors that could lead to hefty fines. Look for a provider that:
- Offers automated tax calculations and filings to avoid penalties.
- Has a strong track record of compliance with IRS and Department of Labor requirements.
- Ensures compliance with federal payroll taxes, managing the complexities and time commitments involved in accurately calculating and remitting these taxes.
- Uses SOC 2, ISO 27001, or other security certifications to safeguard sensitive employee data.
2. Scalability: Can It Grow With Your Business?
Your payroll needs will evolve as your business grows. Whether you expand to multiple states, add contract workers, or enter new markets, your provider should offer:
- Multi-state and international payroll capabilities, if needed.
- The ability to handle both W-2 employees and 1099 contractors.
- Customizable features that adapt to your business size and industry-specific needs.
3. Technology & Automation: Streamline Payroll Processes
Modern payroll providers leverage AI-driven automation, cloud-based platforms, and API integrations to simplify payroll management. Look for:
- Automated payroll processing with direct deposits, tax filings, and benefits administration.
- Seamless integration with accounting (QuickBooks, Xero), HR, and time-tracking software.
- Self-service portals for employees to access pay stubs, tax documents, and benefits.
- Automation of payroll tasks to streamline processes, reduce errors, and save costs.
4. Customer Support: Access to Payroll Experts When You Need Them
Payroll mistakes can disrupt employee satisfaction and lead to compliance issues. The best providers offer:
- Dedicated account managers or 24/7 support to resolve payroll issues quickly.
- U.S.-based support teams that understand state-specific labor laws.
- Live chat, phone, and email support for urgent payroll concerns.
5. Pricing & Cost Transparency: No Hidden Fees
Payroll pricing models vary, so it’s important to choose a provider with clear and predictable pricing. Compare:
- Flat-rate vs. per-employee pricing—some charge a base fee plus a per-employee rate, while others offer a fixed monthly cost.
- Hidden fees for add-ons—check if there are extra costs for tax filings, end-of-year W-2 processing, or direct deposits.
- Long-term contract requirements—opt for flexible pricing structures that align with your business needs.
- Payroll cost variability—payroll cost can fluctuate based on factors like the provider’s location, the specific service package chosen, and the frequency of payroll. Be aware of additional fees that may arise from extra services.
6. Reputation & Industry Expertise: Proven Experience Matters
Not all payroll providers cater to the same industries. If your business has specific compliance requirements (e.g., healthcare, finance, or government contracting), choose a provider with:
- Experience serving businesses in your industry.
- Strong client reviews, case studies, and testimonials.
- Recognition from industry experts or payroll associations.
Top 10 Payroll Outsourcing Companies for U.S. Businesses
Below, we’ve compiled a list of the top 10 payroll outsourcing companies that offer reliable, scalable, and compliant payroll solutions for U.S. businesses. Each provider has distinct features, pricing models, and specialties—whether you need payroll for a small startup, a mid-sized company, or a large enterprise with multi-state operations.
1. 1840 & Company
1840 & Company specializes in helping businesses source, vet, and onboard highly skilled remote payroll specialists, offering a cost-effective alternative to traditional in-house payroll teams. Instead of relying on expensive payroll service providers, companies can leverage top-tier talent at a fraction of the cost, ensuring seamless payroll processing, tax compliance, and benefits administration. Whether you need a single payroll expert or an entire remote payroll team, 1840 & Company provides pre-vetted professionals who integrate into your operations while maintaining compliance with U.S. tax and labor laws. With a global talent network and a focus on scalability and cost efficiency, 1840 & Company is an ideal solution for businesses looking to optimize payroll operations without sacrificing quality or compliance.
2. ADP
ADP is a leading payroll and HR solutions provider, trusted by businesses of all sizes for its scalability, compliance expertise, and automation capabilities. Their payroll services include automated wage calculations, direct deposits, tax filing, and benefits administration, ensuring compliance with federal, state, and local regulations. ADP also offers payroll outsourcing services, providing a flexible solution for businesses through various service agreements. ADP’s platform integrates with HR, time tracking, and accounting software, offering a seamless experience with employee self-service tools and robust analytics. With flexible service tiers like RUN Powered by ADP for small businesses and ADP Workforce Now for larger enterprises, ADP remains a top choice for companies seeking efficient, secure, and customizable payroll outsourcing.
3. Paychex
Paychex is a trusted payroll outsourcing provider specializing in small- and mid-sized businesses, offering a user-friendly platform and expert customer support. Their services include payroll processing, tax filings, benefits administration, and compliance management, ensuring accuracy and efficiency. Paychex also excels in annual payroll tax reporting and provides tools to help businesses stay compliant with federal, state, and local regulations. With scalable solutions and integrations with HR and accounting software, Paychex is a top choice for businesses looking for reliable, all-in-one payroll management.
4. Gusto
Gusto is a popular payroll solution for small to mid-sized businesses, known for its intuitive platform and seamless HR integration. It automates payroll processing, tax filings, and employee deductions, ensuring compliance with federal, state, and local regulations. Gusto also offers built-in benefits administration, allowing businesses to manage health insurance, retirement plans, and workers’ compensation alongside payroll. With an easy-to-use interface, strong customer support, and integrations with accounting and HR tools, Gusto is an excellent choice for businesses seeking a modern, all-in-one payroll and HR solution.
5. Paycor
Paycor offers comprehensive payroll and HR solutions, designed to enhance operational efficiency and workforce management. Its flexible payroll processing allows businesses to customize pay schedules while ensuring compliance with federal, state, and local tax regulations. Paycor also provides advanced reporting, automation tools, and strong customer support, making payroll management more efficient and scalable. With a focus on mid-sized and growing businesses, Paycor is a solid choice for companies seeking a reliable, technology-driven payroll solution.
6. OnPay
OnPay is a cost-effective payroll provider, ideal for small businesses and startups looking for affordable, straightforward payroll management. It automates payroll processing, tax filings, and benefits deductions, ensuring compliance with IRS and state regulations. OnPay’s transparent pricing and robust tax compliance tools help businesses avoid penalties while keeping payroll operations simple and efficient. With a user-friendly interface and no hidden fees, OnPay is a great option for businesses seeking reliable payroll without high costs.
7. TriNet
Trinet is a full-service HR and payroll outsourcing provider, best known for its Professional Employer Organization (PEO) services tailored to small and mid-sized businesses. It offers automated payroll processing, benefits administration, and compliance support, ensuring businesses stay aligned with employment laws and tax regulations. With industry-specific payroll expertise, integrated HR tools, and risk management solutions, TriNet is a strong choice for companies seeking a hands-off, outsourced approach to payroll and HR management.
8. Square Payroll
Square Payroll offers simple, automated payroll processing, making it an excellent choice for small businesses, retail shops, and service-based industries. It seamlessly integrates with Square’s point-of-sale (POS) system, allowing business owners to track employee hours, automate tax filings, and process direct deposits with ease. Square Payroll ensures full compliance with federal, state, and local tax regulations, making payroll efficient and hassle-free for businesses looking for an all-in-one payment and payroll solution.
9. Justworks
Justworks is a Professional Employer Organization (PEO) that provides full-service payroll and HR solutions, making it ideal for growing businesses seeking an all-in-one workforce management platform. It handles payroll processing, benefits administration, compliance support, and tax filings, ensuring businesses stay compliant while simplifying employee compensation. With dedicated HR support and access to enterprise-level benefits, Justworks is a strong option for companies looking to streamline payroll while enhancing employee experience.
10. SurePayroll
SurePayroll is a small-business-focused payroll provider offering affordable, cloud-based payroll services with built-in tax compliance. It automates payroll calculations, direct deposits, and tax filings, reducing administrative burden for business owners. With features like self-service employee portals, benefits administration, and 24/7 customer support, SurePayroll is a reliable choice for startups, freelancers, and small businesses seeking a cost-effective, no-fuss payroll solution.
Payroll Outsourcing: Provider vs. Contractor – Which Is Right for Your Business?
When outsourcing payroll, businesses typically choose between hiring a payroll service provider or working with an independent payroll specialist (contractor). Each option has its advantages, depending on your company’s size, needs, and budget. Below, we break down the key differences to help you decide which approach is best for your business.
Payroll Provider vs. Contractor: Key Differences
| Factor | Payroll Service Provider | Independent Contractor (Payroll Specialist) |
|---|---|---|
| Scope of Service | Fully managed payroll, including tax filings, compliance, and benefits administration. | Payroll processing, but compliance and tax filings may require oversight from the business. |
| Compliance & Risk Management | Ensures full compliance with federal, state, and local tax laws. | Business remains responsible for compliance unless contractor has expertise. |
| Automation & Technology | Offers cloud-based platforms with automation, integrations, and reporting. | May use payroll software but lacks the full automation of a provider. |
| Cost | Typically higher, with monthly fees or per-employee charges. | More cost-effective, especially for smaller teams or businesses needing payroll support without full-service outsourcing. |
| Flexibility & Control | Business follows the provider’s system and processes. | Business has more control over payroll processes and workflows. |
| Scalability | Suitable for businesses of all sizes, especially those with multi-state or international employees. | Best for businesses with smaller payroll needs or those wanting a dedicated specialist. |
| Support & Customer Service | 24/7 support from a corporate help desk, but service may be less personalized. | Direct access to a dedicated payroll specialist with tailored support. |
| Best For | Companies needing a hands-off, fully managed payroll solution. | Businesses looking for a cost-effective payroll expert to integrate into their team. |
Which Option Is Best for Your Business?
- Choose a Payroll Provider if you want a fully managed, automated payroll system that ensures compliance and handles tax filings, direct deposits, and benefits administration. This is ideal for businesses with complex payroll needs, multiple locations, or a growing workforce.
- Hire a Payroll Contractor if you need a dedicated specialist who can provide personalized payroll processing at a lower cost, while still maintaining control over your payroll system. This is a great option for businesses looking for flexibility, cost savings, and hands-on payroll support without committing to a full-service provider.
For companies looking to hire pre-vetted payroll specialists, 1840 & Company can help source, vet, and onboard top-tier remote payroll professionals, providing a cost-effective alternative to traditional payroll outsourcing.
Conclusion
Outsourcing payroll can be a strategic move for businesses looking to save time, reduce compliance risks, and improve payroll accuracy. Whether you choose a full-service payroll provider or hire a dedicated payroll specialist, the right solution depends on your company’s size, complexity, and budget.
The top payroll outsourcing companies listed in this article offer a range of services tailored to different business needs—from automated payroll processing and tax compliance to scalable workforce solutions. By carefully evaluating features like compliance support, technology integration, and pricing transparency, businesses can select a provider that aligns with their long-term goals.
If you’re looking for a cost-effective way to optimize payroll operations, we can help. Schedule a call today to find the right payroll expert for your team!
